Posted: Thu Aug 04, 2011 12:01 pm
Thanks for the replies.. Still working on the shelf but haven't addressed the mounting hardware yet but will if time permits this weekend.. So far I've got all parts cut and ready for assembly but figured I'd stain/coat it before assembly as it would be much easier.. To that end, the following came up..
Ok.. So my Rockler purchased can of Arm-r-Seal (from General Finishes) was running low so I visited the local store again to get more only to find that they no longer carried it because it was banned by the SCAQMDbecause it apparently pollutes too much for LA County! So, the only other compatible product they carried was a Sam Maloof product which is also an oil + urethane mix.. The thing I didn't notice is that it's full-gloss (unlike the Arm-R-Seal which is semi-gloss) and should be applied differently..
So, after I applied it and found none appear to completely dry to the touch (still a little tacky feeling after several days), I finally did some further reading (which I should have done before applying it!!) and found that I should only leave it on for a while and then effectively wipe all of the excess off with a clean rag followed by a drying period. I had assumed I could use the same technique I had used for the Arm-R-Seal but not in this case (I won't make that mistake again).
Anyway, at this point I'm tempted to do a light sanding and try to buff the finish out and see what it looks like.. Is there anything else I should do to rectify this? Unfortunately the gloss is VERY glossy on this finish compared to the Arm-R-Seal and I ended up putting some of it on top of the arm-r-Seal finished pieces to be consistent.
Also, since the bookshelf sits on top of an existing desk (already stained/finished) and that item is NOT glossy I'm half tempted to apply the Maloof product to it as well for consistency.. Is that a bad idea or should I try to tone-down the Maloof finish to be less glossy? I can go either way here..
Ok.. So my Rockler purchased can of Arm-r-Seal (from General Finishes) was running low so I visited the local store again to get more only to find that they no longer carried it because it was banned by the SCAQMDbecause it apparently pollutes too much for LA County! So, the only other compatible product they carried was a Sam Maloof product which is also an oil + urethane mix.. The thing I didn't notice is that it's full-gloss (unlike the Arm-R-Seal which is semi-gloss) and should be applied differently..
So, after I applied it and found none appear to completely dry to the touch (still a little tacky feeling after several days), I finally did some further reading (which I should have done before applying it!!) and found that I should only leave it on for a while and then effectively wipe all of the excess off with a clean rag followed by a drying period. I had assumed I could use the same technique I had used for the Arm-R-Seal but not in this case (I won't make that mistake again).
Anyway, at this point I'm tempted to do a light sanding and try to buff the finish out and see what it looks like.. Is there anything else I should do to rectify this? Unfortunately the gloss is VERY glossy on this finish compared to the Arm-R-Seal and I ended up putting some of it on top of the arm-r-Seal finished pieces to be consistent.
Also, since the bookshelf sits on top of an existing desk (already stained/finished) and that item is NOT glossy I'm half tempted to apply the Maloof product to it as well for consistency.. Is that a bad idea or should I try to tone-down the Maloof finish to be less glossy? I can go either way here..